Maine’s Crucial Senate Race: Old Politics vs. New Politics
The political spotlight is on Maine as Democratic candidate Troy Jackson challenges incumbent Sen. Susan Collins in a pivotal U.S. Senate race. This election could determine if Democrats gain control of the Senate from Republicans.
Voters in Maine face a significant choice. On one hand, they see Sen. Collins, who has funneled millions to the state. Reelecting her ensures Republican Senate control. On the other hand, Democrat Jackson represents a shift in political philosophy.
Old Politics vs. New Politics
The legacy of old politics harks back to the late House Speaker Tip O’Neill, who emphasized the importance of earmarking federal funds locally. Sen. Collins exemplifies this approach. First elected in 1996, she chairs the Senate Appropriations Committee, with campaigns highlighting her ability to secure funds, including $190 million for rural hospitals.
The new politics operates on national sentiments, expanding divisions between blue and red states. Figures such as Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders symbolize these shifts. Trump attracts older, less educated voters from rural areas, while Sanders appeals to young, urban, and college-educated demographics.
Troy Jackson: A Political Journey
Jackson’s political career started as a Republican in Maine’s rural areas. After failing to win a state House seat in 2000, he switched parties and successfully ran as a Democrat in 2004. His career advanced to state Senate positions, ultimately supporting Sanders during his presidential bid.
Following Graham Platner’s campaign failure, Jackson secured the Democratic nomination. In his acceptance, Jackson criticized Collins for supporting corporate tax breaks and confirming Supreme Court justices who overturned Roe v. Wade. He champions policies like abolishing ICE and Medicare for All.
Voter Perspectives
Elderly voters like Frank Bragg, once a Collins supporter, now back Jackson for broader national interests. Citing past Senator Margaret Chase Smith, Bragg criticizes Collins for not opposing Trump decisively.
While millions pour into political advertising, the race may hinge on the “double haters” who dislike both candidates. Trump describes Jackson as a “lunatic” and socialist; Jackson criticizes Collins as a Trump ally. Collins relies on split-ticket voters, but this election may see fewer of them as Maine transitions to national political divides.
This analysis is provided by John Kenneth White, professor emeritus at The Catholic University of America, coauthor of “Democracy on the Edge.” Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved.