- November 22, 2026
- Updated 9:59 am
Review of ‘Adirondack Chair Circle’ at Steppenwolf Theatre
- 30 Views
- admin
- November 2, 2026
- Entertainment
Stephanie Alison Walker’s new play, ‘Adirondack Chair Circle,’ is rooted in a narrative about a suburban mother grappling with her child’s nonbinary identity. This mother, portrayed by Katrina Lenk, navigates unfamiliar support systems in a search for belonging. Directed by Pam MacKinnon, the production has a world-class lead actress whose expressive performance captures the character’s nuance.
Expectations might lean toward a daring exploration of personal struggle and societal norms. Instead, Steppenwolf Theatre Company presents a familiar moral satire. Satire traditionally critiques power. This play doesn’t quite fit that mold, as conservative moms in the audience are unlikely to be eager to incite controversy or book bans.
Walker’s comedy reflects the audience’s existing views, rather than challenging them. Historically, Steppenwolf audiences have engaged with provocative performances, seeking to be challenged and enlightened. This play, however, opts for ideological safety, avoiding bold confrontations with complex themes.
‘Adirondack Chair Circle’ portrays three eccentric conservative mothers discussing educational content. The discussion centers around book selection in schools, advocating the professional judgment of librarians and educators. Caroline Neff plays the liberal, reasonable opposition, welcoming conversations about challenging topics such as sex.
While exploring conservative divisions, the play neglects liberal complexities. Sadieh Rifai represents the extreme stance, while Lenk’s character sits between divisive viewpoints. Despite humor and quirk, Mateo’s performance reveals a likable persona amidst the conservative spectrum. Conversely, liberal perspectives appear unified, with limited character representation.
Set during a tense Chicago school board election, this backdrop provides rich material for dramatic exploration. Yet, the play’s depiction of book-banning protests lacks the nuanced portrayal it promises. Despite this, comedic moments, like David Darrow’s crow antics, offer entertainment, though the humor grows repetitive over time.
Pam MacKinnon adeptly utilizes Steppenwolf’s theater space, ensuring engaging performances. However, Katrina Lenk’s portrayal hints at a deeper character potential. While plays with moral or political points have influenced change, successful satire demands introspection and self-critique, which this play seems reluctant to embrace.
The late Richard Greenberg’s brother remarked on Greenberg’s talent for using eloquent dialogue to express opposing views sharply. This reflection could guide future productions like ‘Adirondack Chair Circle,’ fostering genuine, thought-provoking storytelling.
Chris Jones is a critic for the Tribune.
Review: ‘Adirondack Chair Circle’ (2.5 stars)
Running until Dec. 13
Location: Steppenwolf’s Ensemble Theater, 1646 N. Halsted St.
Duration: 2 hours, 30 minutes
Tickets: $20-167.50 via 312-335-1650 and steppenwolf.org