- November 22, 2026
- Updated 9:59 am
Trial Revives Details of Decades-Old Murder Case
- 69 Views
- admin
- November 5, 2026
- Uncategorized
Paula Turley last communicated with her friend, Karen Snider, on the morning of November 12, 1966. They discussed feeding their baby daughters and Turley’s upcoming birthday. Turley, now 79, gave her testimony on Wednesday. ‘We talked every morning,’ Turley stated.
That evening, Snider, aged 18, was discovered stabbed to death in her home in Calumet City. At that time, Turley was married to James Barbier. In 2024, Barbier was arrested in Missouri and accused of first-degree murder in Snider’s death, after the case had gone unsolved for decades. His trial began Tuesday.
Barbier had worked with Snider’s husband at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad. The two couples were close friends, according to Turley. Both she and Snider had daughters in August 1966. ‘She was my best friend,’ Turley said. Later that day, Turley recalled her parents and brother visiting her at their Gary, Indiana home. She testified that Barbier returned home around dusk. Although she didn’t see him enter, she became aware of his presence when she heard the washing machine running in the basement. This behavior was unusual for him. She saw him only when he came upstairs. ‘He was in clean clothes then,’ Turley stated. ‘He had cuts on his face.’
Cook County Chief Medical Examiner Ponni Arunkumar testified that Snider was stabbed more than 120 times. She received 18 stab wounds to her neck, while other wounds targeted her chest and abdomen. ‘Many penetrated ribs and entered the ribcage,’ Arunkumar reported.
Arunkumar noted that the neck wounds damaged her larynx, jugular vein, and carotid artery, some being deep enough to impact her spine. Abdominal injuries reached her heart, aorta, and liver, and her hands showed defensive wounds.
Turley mentioned that Barbier served as a pallbearer at Snider’s funeral, his face still bandaged. After Snider’s death, Barbier moved to Missouri, and they divorced the following year. Turley remarked on not receiving any financial support from him.
Assistant Public Defender Tom Justic questioned Turley’s recollection of events from 60 years ago, highlighting alleged discrepancies in her testimony. ‘You don’t remember much about November 12, 1966, do you?’ Justic asked. He highlighted that Turley previously claimed to have seen Barbier return home, contradicting her current testimony. Differences existed in her descriptions of his facial injuries over time.
The trial saw testimony from former Chicago police Capt. John Collins, 91, who detailed processing the crime scene as an evidence technician. In 1966, technicians did not wear gloves, and DNA was not understood. Collins noted that all crime scene photos were in black and white. The trial continues at the Markham Courthouse.