Criticism Arises Over NYC’s Public Property Owner Database

Scott Galloway, a well-known liberal podcaster and NYU professor, has criticized New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. This follows the release of a publicly accessible database listing affluent property owners potentially subject to a new pied-à-terre tax. Critics express concerns over risks like harassment and public safety threats.

The database, released by the city’s Department of Finance, allows public searches of properties with owner names and addresses. A department spokesperson stated that state law required the publication of this property roll.

Galloway, speaking on the “Pivot” podcast, voiced his objections. He highlighted the risks of what he described as doxing, which involves publishing private information potentially exposing people to harm. Although he supports the tax, Galloway criticized the list’s presentation as akin to a “wanted poster.”

Addressing Mamdani’s approach, Galloway argued that it played into conservative fears. He stressed the importance of celebrating success in New York instead of demonizing it, as the city is a hub for aspirational achievement in various fields. He noted that 95% of those listed might not be subject to the tax, questioning the rationale behind releasing such details.

In response, the Real Estate Board of New York President, James Whelan, described the tax rollout as flawed. Whelan expressed concerns over the complexity of determining tax liability.

Mamdani’s office countered by stating that the publication of property tax rolls is standard and in line with legal requirements. They emphasized that these rolls have historically been published as part of routine procedures across many cities in New York State.

“We publish property tax rolls in accordance with the law,” the mayor’s office stated, clarifying that the recent roll reflects all properties, not just those subject to the pied-à-terre tax.

The database contains every property parcel’s details, used to identify which are subject to the surcharge. This practice, consistent with laws, aligns with procedures followed for other surcharges.

Additional responses highlighted that similar tax rolls exist in cities like Nassau and Rochester. A Bloomberg reporter noted that such data has long been publicly available, emphasizing the routine nature of this release.