Choosing the Best Food Coloring for Your Baked Creations

Few things are as delightful as a freshly-filled pastry case adorned with beautifully decorated cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. While a baker’s skill is crucial, food coloring is another tool that enhances these creations. Using the best food coloring can make your baked goods even more vibrant.

Top Picks for Food Coloring

To start with a trusted name in baking, consider the Wilton Icing Colors 12-Piece Gel Food Coloring Set. This set offers a wide range of easy-to-use gel colors.

Types of Food Coloring

Gel vs. Liquid

Many professional bakers prefer gel food coloring for its ability to deliver deep, vibrant colors without diluting batters or frostings. It is especially useful in candy making and works well with temperamental white chocolate and fondant. Liquid food coloring, meanwhile, is more convenient and easy to use; simply add drops to reach your desired color. Liquid coloring often comes in larger sizes and is more affordable, making it the budget-friendly choice.

Color Combinations

You can start with three primary colors and mix them to create a rainbow of hues. However, a multi-color kit is ideal for those who prefer predefined mixes, ensuring consistent color results.

Natural Dyes

Typically, commercial-grade food coloring consists of artificial colors. While most people don’t notice any taste, some sensitive individuals may detect artificial flavors when colors are used heavily. If you’re sensitive to artificial ingredients or want to preserve the taste of your baking, opt for natural dyes. These are made from foods and spices and, while often more muted, achieve similar effects without artificial ingredients. Note that natural dyes can be harder to find and more expensive than traditional dyes.

Traits of Quality Food Coloring

Vibrant, True Colors

Achieving vibrant and true colors is essential, even if your goal is the lightest pastels.

Variety

A wide selection of colors expands your baking repertoire. Starting with a color kit featuring at least red, yellow, blue, and green will help you gradually build your collection.

Easy to Mix

Mixing food coloring should be simple and not problematic like gel color, which can be stiff and sticky.

Price Expectations

Expect to spend between $10 and $15 on high-quality food coloring.

Additional Types of Food Coloring

There are four more types of food coloring: liquid gel, powdered, oil-based, and airbrush. These are used primarily by professional bakers and may be found online or in specialty baking stores.

Usage Tips

No matter what you are coloring, patience is key. Add food coloring drop by drop to avoid deep saturation. Remember, gel color is concentrated, so starting with a toothpick’s worth is ideal. Mix thoroughly, let it rest, and reevaluate the color in natural light. Keep in mind that colors may darken in frosting and fondant but lighten during baking.

Leading Food Coloring Options

Top Choice: Wilton Icing Colors 12-Piece Gel Food Coloring Set

Pros: Gel food coloring mixes well without watering down batters, doughs, fondant, and frosting. The colors are bright, requiring minimal use.

Cons: The small jars can be challenging to maneuver.

Top for Value: Nomeca Vibrant Food Color Liquid Dye

Pros: Easy to use and affordable for beginners. Dispenses one drop at a time for precise control without noticeable flavor.

Cons: Less vibrant compared to other options.

Worth Considering: Supernatural Store Plant-Based Food Color

Pros: Vegan, gluten-free, and kosher with vegetable and fruit-based colorants.

Cons: Color consistency may vary, and it can be difficult to mix smoothly.

Prices reflect time and date of publication and are subject to change. For daily deals and shopping inspiration, sign up for the BestReviews weekly newsletter. BestReviews and its partners may earn a commission from affiliate links.