Investigation Continues at Fox Hollow Farm: Coroner Seeks Truth from Key Figure

Nearly 30 years after thousands of human bones were found at the estate of suspected serial killer Herb Baumeister, new questions arise about the events at Fox Hollow Farm. Hamilton County Coroner Jeff Jellison is leading a renewed investigation. He suggests a crucial individual in the case, Mark Goodyear, may not have been fully transparent with the authorities.

Jellison, speaking to Fox News Digital, emphasized the importance of honesty in the investigation. ‘I have asked Mark Goodyear questions where I already knew the answers, and he was not truthful,’ said Jellison. ‘To have a meaningful conversation with him, he must be willing to be honest.’

Jellison’s goal is to identify the remains found on the 18-acre property once owned by Baumeister.

Baumeister, suspected of killing at least 25 men in Indiana, died by suicide before his arrest. Authorities unearthed approximately 10,000 bone fragments on the property. Mark Goodyear, who claims to be Baumeister’s only known survivor, has never faced charges related to the case. Yet Jellison believes Goodyear might possess information crucial for identifying the remaining victims.

The documentary ‘Return to Fox Hollow: New Victims, Darker Secrets’ explores new theories about possible accomplices, overlooked evidence, and witness testimonies. It is a follow-up to the 2025 docuseries ‘The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer.’

‘Were you familiar with anybody?’ Jellison wants to ask. ‘Information that can help identify the remains and explain how these people died is vital.’

Goodyear’s knowledge of people through gay nightclubs could assist in identifying some victims. He initially agreed to participate in the follow-up documentary but did not appear for the interview. A voicemail left by him is heard in the film.

Investigators suspect Baumeister lured men from gay bars in Indianapolis to his home, killed them, and disposed of their remains on his property. The bizarre case gained notoriety in the true crime series community, with claims of Baumeister possibly filming his victims.

There are critical questions regarding the ability of one person to commit these crimes alone. ‘The placement of evidence raises this question,’ said Jellison. ‘How did one man manage to handle these tasks alone?’

Jellison is determined to name the unknown victims, acknowledging that some families might not realize their loved ones vanished into what became known as Fox Hollow Farm.

With over 9,000 bones still unexamined, Jellison’s work continues. ‘Some people didn’t have close family connections. Families might be unaware their relative was a victim here,’ he said. He stressed the importance of coming forward for those who suspect a missing loved one might be involved.

Jellison draws parallels to the World Trade Center recovery efforts. ‘In some ways, this investigation is more complex,’ he explained, noting the lack of records or missing-person reports associated with these remains.

Jellison encourages anyone with potential information to contact his office, which received about 500 responses after the original documentary aired. ‘If you think your missing loved one could be connected, reach out. I’ll guide you in the right direction.’