- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:31 am
Judge Orders Release of Canadian Dentist Detained by ICE
- 47 Views
- admin
- November 2, 2026
- Court News
A federal judge in Minnesota has mandated the immediate release of a Canadian dentist, William Virgil Lizardo, who was detained by ICE following a mishandling of his immigration hearing notice. Judge Michael J. Davis ruled that Lizardo’s arrest violated the Fourth and Fifth Amendments.
William Virgil Lizardo, 32, from Mississauga, Ontario, was ordered to be released by U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis. Lizardo’s detention came after a hearing notice was sent to an outdated address according to immigration records. Davis condemned the error as depriving Lizardo of his liberty without due process.
“The hubris of admitting that USCIS made a big mistake, but not even offering any sort of relief is galling, although not surprising,” Davis stated in his November 1 order.
Lizardo was to be freed by 6 p.m. Sunday, with restrictions preventing his re-arrest, transfer, or deportation without court approval. This decision underscores ongoing tensions between federal judges and ICE regarding immigration enforcement limits.
Lizardo entered the U.S. on a student visa in 2019 to study at the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry. He graduated in 2023 and married a U.S. citizen. His wife filed a petition in September 2023 to adjust Lizardo’s status to permanent residency, approved in January 2025.
USCIS denied Lizardo’s permanent residency application in January 2026, citing a missing court record from an Ontario case. Lizardo appealed, with the case pending during the judge’s ruling.
In early 2026, DHS issued a Notice to Appear for a March immigration court hearing, mistakenly sent to an old address. Lizardo missed the hearing and was removed in absentia.
He learned of his removal order on October 23 when appearing for an immigration interview. ICE agents arrested him afterward, and he was detained at Sherburne County Jail. Lizardo contested the removal order due to lack of notice, and the court reopened the case on October 28.
Davis dismissed the government’s argument that Lizardo’s detention was valid under different immigration laws, stating no new warrant or determination supported his detention. Lizardo’s record of attending appointments when properly notified contradicted claims of him being a flight risk.
Judge Davis wrote, “It strains credulity to think that such a petitioner would flee.”
Lizardo’s habeas corpus petition was granted, releasing him on his recognizance. Officials were ordered to return his belongings and barred from future detention or removal without the court’s permission.
Future detention requests must identify legal authority and changed circumstances. The government must prove that release conditions wouldn’t ensure community safety and Lizardo’s court appearances.
Davis’ ruling doesn’t guarantee Lizardo’s permanent residency, as his immigration case remains active post-rescinding of the removal order.