- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:26 am
Alaska’s Senate Race Controversy Over ‘Ballot Stacking’
- 31 Views
- admin
- November 2, 2026
- Election Coverage Politics
The situation involving two candidates named Dan Sullivan in Alaska’s U.S. Senate election mirrors a 2020 incident in Florida. In that case, a former Republican state senator was accused of enlisting a candidate with a similar name to the Democratic incumbent in order to divert votes. While Alaska’s allegations are still under investigation, both cases highlight a practice known as ‘ballot stacking’ where candidates with similar names appear on ballots. In the U.S., this strategy is more prevalent than one might expect and is generally not illegal.
The Case of the Two Dan Sullivans in Alaska
Alaska’s ranked choice voting system had the top four primary candidates appear on the November 3 ballot. These candidates include former congresswoman Mary Peltola, running as a Democrat, incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher and fishing enthusiast who initially filed as a Republican, and Gerald “Jerry” Heikes, a drywall contractor also running as a Republican.
The inclusion of a second Dan Sullivan concerned President Donald Trump. He criticized the ranked choice voting system and accused the Democrats of “cheating” by placing a misleading candidate on the ballot. Alaska’s election authorities also questioned Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy, initially finding it questionable. However, an Alaska trial court decision in June reinstated him on the ballot.
The controversy intensified when Trump directed his administration to sue to block certification of the election results if Senator Sullivan lost, claiming votes for Sullivan Jr. could have affected the outcome. The lawsuit suggests Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy intended to assist the Peltola campaign by reducing votes for Senator Sullivan. Peltola’s team, along with the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, moved to dismiss the lawsuit, accusing Trump’s administration of laying groundwork for unlawful challenges to a potential Peltola victory.
A report by The New York Times alleged Democrats in Alaska attempted to recruit someone named Dan Sullivan to draw votes from Senator Sullivan. Elisa Rios, Peltola’s former campaign manager, mentioned efforts to recruit Sullivan Jr., who later changed his affiliation to “undeclared.” Peltola denied knowledge of recruiting another Sullivan, but was “definitely aware” according to Rios.
A federal judge in Alaska dismissed the lawsuit, ruling actions sought by the Trump administration did not address voter confusion concerns. Though experts called the Department of Justice’s lawsuit “meritless,” they acknowledged real concerns about voter confusion. Investigations into Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy continue, labeled as “ballot stacking,” which, while common, is generally legal in U.S. elections.
Florida’s 2020 State Senate Election: Two Rodriguez on the Ballot
In Florida’s 2020 state Senate race, Jose Javier Rodriguez, the Democratic incumbent, faced Alex Rodriguez, an independent, alongside Republican Ileana Garcia. Garcia narrowly defeated Jose Javier Rodriguez by 32 votes, while Alex Rodriguez collected over 6,000 votes. Former Republican senator Frank Artiles faced charges for recruiting Alex Rodriguez as a “sham candidate” to siphon votes from the Democratic incumbent, involving illegal campaign donations.
Alex Rodriguez accepted illegal donations and agreed to testify against Artiles. Artiles was later convicted of conspiracy charges, serving probation and jail time for the election scheme. Ileana Garcia, uninvolved in the scheme, retained her seat and was reelected in 2022, becoming a noted critic of Trump’s immigration policies. Artiles was not found guilty of falsifying voter registration forms.
Insights from the Florida and Alaska Ballot Controversies
Frank Artiles’s conviction in Florida involved illegal campaign finance activities, which differ from legal “ballot stacking.” No claims in Alaska suggest payment to Sullivan Jr. to run, although actions to recruit him were reported. Peltola’s involvement in these efforts remains unproven.
Attorney General Todd Blanche and Trump accused ballot stacking in Alaska of “voter fraud.” Despite differentiation efforts, concerns about voter confusion persist. FairVote explained Alaska’s ranked choice voting system reduces risks of splitting votes between similarly named candidates, as voters can rank both, ensuring votes count for the presumed stronger candidate.