- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:36 am
Supreme Court Considers Case Involving State-Funded Pre-K Program
The Supreme Court appears poised to decide whether children of gay and trans parents can be excluded from a state-funded pre-K program. The case arose after Colorado launched a program in 2022 to provide all four-year-olds with early education. Taxpayers fund the program at $6,300 per child annually, and it is open to all groups, including religious institutions.
The program requires adherence to nondiscrimination laws, which prohibit prejudice based on race, religion, ethnicity, or other categorizations. Initially, the Catholic Church supported this initiative, and Catholic Charities continues to participate. Nevertheless, the Denver archdiocese argues that enforcing nondiscrimination infringes on religious freedoms protected by the Constitution. The archdiocese seeks exemption from the law so that it can receive funding while excluding children of gay and trans parents.
The court’s conservative majority seems open to the archdiocese’s request. Justice Neil Gorsuch criticized Colorado for allegedly overlooking previous court decisions. Justice Amy Coney Barrett questioned the state’s intentions. Justice Brett Kavanaugh suggested a compromise could accommodate religious beliefs and still enable LGBT parents to find suitable schools. Justice Samuel Alito noted a lack of evidence that LGBT couples cannot find other preschools.
Colorado’s Deputy Solicitor General, Helen Norton, highlighted difficulties faced by specific families, such as the need for schools with early hours or the ability to accommodate siblings together. She disputed claims that these schools are interchangeable.
The liberal justices clearly disagreed with the conservatives. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson argued against distinguishing exclusions based on sexual orientation from those based on race. Justice Elena Kagan critiqued the perceived need for special treatment for religious groups. Justice Sonia Sotomayor challenged the archdiocese’s representative, Nicholas R. Reaves, on the implications of rejecting children due to their parents’ sexual orientation.
Among conservatives, Chief Justice John Roberts alone exhibited skepticism regarding the archdiocese’s stance. A decision from the court is anticipated by summer 2027.