- November 22, 2026
- Updated 7:43 am
Alaska Judge Rules Against Campaign’s Request for Absentee Ballot List
- 23 Views
- admin
- November 13, 2026
- Election Coverage Politics
An Alaska judge decided on Wednesday that the request by Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign for a list of voters whose absentee ballots were rejected is “not reasonable”. This decision arises amid the ongoing count of ballots from last week’s election.
The election features a ranked voting system where Peltola competes against Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. Alaska remains the only undecided Senate race in the country. The state allows ballots from overseas voters to be received up to 15 days post-election, making November 18 the deadline. This is also the target date for the Division of Elections to conduct ranked vote tabulations if no candidate secures more than 50% of the initial votes.
Last Friday, Peltola’s campaign attorneys sued state officials, seeking a list detailing rejected absentee ballots and the reasons for their rejection. Their aim was to ensure all qualified votes are included, but state attorneys argued that supplying this information would breach voter privacy. They contended that producing the list would be an “electronic service or product”, which state law does not prioritize over the agency’s primary tasks.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews, in his ruling, suggested that redaction of the voter database records could theoretically allow their release. However, he noted the division is not obligated to disclose them since they “cannot reasonably be produced at this juncture, nor redacted of confidential information.” Matthews emphasized the division’s commitment to its “fundamental responsibility” in managing the election process amid tight deadlines.
The law firm representing Peltola’s campaign did not comment immediately following the decision, as Wednesday was a holiday. The state Department of Law, representing the Division of Elections, expressed satisfaction with the judge’s ruling.
During arguments on Tuesday, Peltola’s attorney, Abha Khanna, stated the campaign did not intend to disrupt the ballot counting. She described the absentee ballot review process as “incredibly smoothly”. Khanna argued the sought information was public and in line with what campaign observers access in locations where review boards meet. Their aim was centralized access to this information.
State attorneys maintained that the division’s reports during the absentee ballot review are not public records due to containing confidential details and their status as “ephemeral working documents not intended for preservation.” Michaela Thompson, who manages the absentee ballot review boards, affirmed in an affidavit that the report version given to observers — including those connected to campaigns — lacks most confidential information. However, it still includes voters’ home addresses, which many prefer to keep private.
Observers must sign confidentiality agreements prohibiting them from retaining, copying, or recording report information. Thompson explained that the division’s “old, inflexible” database cannot generate a report excluding confidential addresses, suggesting a vendor would be necessary to create a more specific report.