Judge Dismisses Lawsuit on Religious Liberty Commission’s Legitimacy

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit against the Religious Liberty Commission established under President Donald Trump. The lawsuit, filed by an interfaith group, challenged the commission’s predominantly conservative Christian composition, citing a lack of viewpoint diversity.

Judge’s Ruling

Judge John P. Cronan stated that while federal law mandates advisory commissions to have a balanced range of viewpoints, the law does not specify how this balance should be achieved. He emphasized that the president has considerable discretion in choosing commission members.

Background of the Lawsuit

The plaintiffs included the progressive Interfaith Alliance and groups representing Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh communities. They argued the commission was primarily made up of conservative Christians, with only one Orthodox Jewish rabbi. Critics pointed out concerns regarding the commissioners’ views on church-state separation and their advocacy for America as a Judeo-Christian nation. These concerns were underscored when the commission released a draft report in June, proposing “bridges” between church and state.

Judge’s Legal Arguments

Judge Cronan ruled the lawsuit did not meet the necessary legal standards to proceed. He mentioned that the commission was diverse in other aspects by including both clergy and lay members, covering at least five different religious groups. This was based on having a Jewish member and various Christian denominational representatives.

The Interfaith Alliance contended that the commission favored religious expressions over civil rights for minority groups. However, Judge Cronan concluded that the executive order establishing the commission did not require appointing individuals who oppose the concept of religious liberty as harmonious with civil rights.

Interfaith Alliance’s Criticism

The Interfaith Alliance has criticized the commission’s draft report for neglecting critical issues such as anti-Muslim violence. They argue the commission encourages policies that favor certain religious communities over others.

Note: Associated Press religion coverage receives funding through collaboration with The Conversation US and Lilly Endowment Inc., with AP holding sole responsibility for the content.