The Most Surprising College Football Teams Defying Preseason Rankings
Recently, preseason polls in college football have sparked frustration among fans. When the AP Poll is released, many feel their team is under-ranked. While these polls mark the start of the football season, they can also stir strong emotions.
Several teams have defied expectations by achieving great success despite low preseason rankings. Here, we explore five notable examples from the 21st century.
2025 Indiana Hoosiers (Preseason #20)
The Indiana Hoosiers serve as a perfect example of exceeding predictions. Initially viewed as unlikely to repeat their prior successes, they not only returned to the College Football Playoff but claimed the national title. Coach Curt Cignetti’s astute leadership and Fernando Mendoza’s stellar performance were key to this triumph.
2013 Florida State Seminoles (Preseason #11)
The 2013 Florida State Seminoles began the season just outside the top ten but ended as the last BCS champions. Despite losing veteran players, the team, led by redshirt freshman Jameis Winston, won the national title. They defeated strong opponents with dominant performances, proving doubters wrong.
2000 Oklahoma Sooners (Preseason #19)
Starting with a modest ranking, the Oklahoma Sooners achieved a perfect season under second-year coach Bob Stoops. Their victory over a strong Florida State team cemented their place as national champions. The offense played a significant role, scoring heavily against top teams, including the Texas Longhorns.
2002 Ohio State Buckeyes (Preseason #13)
With a new coach and modest expectations, Ohio State surprised many. They allowed minimal points throughout their conference schedule. Their crowning achievement was defeating a historically strong Miami team in the national championship, despite being significant underdogs.
2010 Auburn Tigers (Preseason #22)
The Auburn Tigers, led by quarterback Cam Newton, achieved an unexpected perfect season. Despite being seen as a team with limited prospects, Newton’s MVP-level performance helped the Tigers secure a national championship. The team struggled after Newton’s departure, highlighting his pivotal role.
These teams demonstrate that preseason rankings can’t predict everything. Their stories exemplify resilience and unexpected success in college football.