Rich Eisen Steps Down as NFL Network Play-by-Play Commentator

Rich Eisen has announced that he will not continue as a play-by-play commentator for NFL games following ESPN’s acquisition of NFL Network. When asked by Sports Illustrated about continuing this role in the upcoming season, Eisen stated, “I believe I am done.”

Since around 2018, Eisen has been calling games for NFL Network, particularly focusing on the network’s international broadcasts, with Kurt Warner often joining as the color analyst. However, sources indicate that ESPN decided to remove Eisen from the game broadcasts. Dave Pasch is slated to replace him on NFL Network-exclusive games. Pasch is leaving his position with the Arizona Cardinals and is highly regarded for his play-by-play skills, recognized as one of ESPN’s top voices.

Eisen’s commentary style faced criticism from fans and media. Observers noted his inclination towards clichés, talking over replays, and relying on a limited vocabulary. He often referred to midfield as “the shield” and his commentary styles were marked by passive voice.

During an interview, Eisen reflected on these challenges, attributing them to the instincts developed as a studio host. He explained, “I enjoyed doing it a lot, man. But it’s so counter to what I normally do… Sitting in this chair on this set, if there’s dead air, my instinct is to jump in and fill the void. Calling a game requires the opposite; you need to be quiet after the big moment.” This contrast highlights the difficulty in excelling both as a studio host and a play-by-play announcer, with Mike Tirico of NBC being one of few exceptions.

Despite stepping down from play-by-play commentary, Eisen’s reputation at ESPN remains intact. He had already signed a separate deal with ESPN, ensuring the continuation of his daily radio show on ESPN Radio and Disney+, as well as hosting special editions of SportsCenter.

Eisen is a polarizing figure within the industry. He is viewed by many as a talented studio anchor and a recognizable face for casual sports fans. Nonetheless, he is criticized for fixating on his own nostalgia, with frequent references to his experiences from 20 or 25 years ago. Additionally, Eisen’s political engagements might not align with ESPN’s current direction, evidenced by his choice of guests on his radio show, including notable names like Doug Emhoff, Gov. Josh Shapiro, Tim Walz, and Jake Tapper.

Eisen’s contribution to sports broadcasting is still appreciated, though ESPN identified his strength lies outside play-by-play commentary in their inaugural season operating NFL Network.