Girl Scouts Responds to Criticism Over Islamic Badge Programs

Girl Scouts and Islamic Badge Controversy

Recently, the Girl Scouts of the USA addressed criticism over social media posts about Islamic faith-based badge programs. The backlash arose after Natalie Winters, a White House correspondent, claimed that the Girl Scouts offered badges related to Islamic practices. Winters noted these programs involve learning about Islamic practices, such as the pillars of Islam and mosque visits, and include locations like Sacramento, Naperville, Long Island, Virginia, Maryland, Brooklyn, and San Diego.

“Mosque-based programs operate in various areas—embedding prayer, hijab rules, Ramadan, Islamic education and mosque outreach into Girl Scouting.” — Natalie Winters

Girl Scouts’ Response

The Girl Scouts clarified through a statement that misinformation was circulating regarding their programs and religion. They noted:

• Girl Scouts is not a religious organization and does not teach religion.
• Girls of all faiths and backgrounds are welcome.
• The national My Promise, My Faith pin encourages girls to connect the Girl Scout Law with their faith.
• Faith-based patches are developed independently and not by Girl Scouts of the USA.

The organization stated, “Girl Scouts is proudly for every girl.”

Continued Criticism

Winters persisted in her stance, accusing Girl Scouts of labeling her information as misinformation. She argued that recognizing Islam in its programs conflicted with the feminism goals, criticizing the treatment of women under Islamic regimes.

Perspective from CAIR

Robert S. McCaw from the Council on American-Islamic Relations commented the initiative aimed at creating outrage against Muslim participation in scouting programs detracted from the true focus on children’s welfare.

“Using Muslim youth as fodder for sensationalism and anti-Muslim hysteria harms public discourse.” — Robert McCaw

Badges and Programs Under Scrutiny

The discussion focused on “Girl Scouts of the Islamic Faith” awards and patches connected to Islamic organizations. These efforts include medals for Muslim Girl Scouts, with activities related to Ramadan, Hajj, Jumaa, and other Islamic aspects.

Broader Debate on Faith-Based Programming

This issue marks a broader conversation within scouting on religious awards. Historically, scouting organizations have supported programs from multiple faiths, allowing members to explore beliefs through badges. CAIR emphasized that Islamic awards are part of the long-standing multi-faith recognition in scouting, not unique exceptions.

Supporters believe these programs enhance girls’ connections with faith communities, while critics worry it blurs cultural education with religious instruction.

Jason Lemon and Sam Wilson of Newsweek contributed to covering this story.