Poll Highlights Shifting Views on American Identity

As the United States approaches a major celebration, a new poll reveals a decline in the number of Americans who view the nation as exceptional. The survey, conducted by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, underscores a growing anxiety, especially among young people, regarding the future of the U.S. government. This sentiment stands in contrast to the national commemorations of the country’s 250th anniversary.

According to the poll, only one-quarter of Americans believe the U.S. surpasses all other nations. In contrast, 44% think it is one of the greatest among several countries. Notably, around 30% now believe there are nations better than the U.S., up from 19% in 2016. The findings also point to a divide over whether diversity is a fundamental aspect of American identity.

Declining Importance of Democracy

The survey shows a decline in the belief that a democratically elected government is vital to the nation’s identity. Currently, about two-thirds of U.S. adults consider it highly important, down from 80% in 2021. Derricka Wall, a 24-year-old from Alabama, attributes the issue not to democracy itself but to those in office. She feels historical safeguards are not functioning effectively.

“It’s not that the democracy part is not working. It’s the people that are actually being put in office that is the problem.”

Young adults are less likely than older Americans to consider the U.S. special. About 44% of those under 30 believe other countries are better compared to 22% of those 60 and older. This generational gap also extends to views on democracy, with only half of adults under 30 seeing it as crucial to U.S. identity, in contrast to 81% of older adults.

“I feel like they would actually roll out of their graves. I feel they would be very disappointed in us.”

The age-related differences in perception are also mirrored in political alignment. Kent Stage, a retired Army enlisted man, argues that the political system fails to address national issues. He advocates for political reforms, including term limits and the inclusion of working-class individuals in government.

Perceptions of the American Dream

Roughly 51% of Americans doubt the current viability of the American Dream, a belief that hard work leads to success. About a third maintain that it continues to be true, while 15% never embraced it. Jack Hermanson, a 27-year-old in Denver, lost faith in this ideal after witnessing his spouse’s job search difficulties. Only 22% of those under 30 now affirm the American Dream, compared to 46% of older Americans.

Angela Toombs, 31, faced with economic hurdles, reflects on the generational shift in financial stability. Among political affiliations, skepticism persists, with most Republicans still supporting the idea, in contrast to just 17% of Democrats.

“I’ll trust the ambulance-chasing lawyer and a shady used car salesman before I trust the politician.”

Quintin Sharpe, a 28-year-old from Wisconsin, embodies a more optimistic American narrative. He remains confident in meritocracy and the potential for success in the U.S.

Diversity as a Defining Factor

Views on diversity and its role in American identity show division. While 56% value a shared culture, down from 65% in 2017, opinions on multiculturalism are mixed. About half of the population sees opportunities for immigrants as integral to national identity, with a significant divide between Republicans and Democrats on this matter.

Rose Nunez, a caregiver from San Antonio, describes pervasive unease about immigration status, highlighting her concerns about the nation’s mood even in celebratory times.

“It is hard to celebrate when the feelings towards immigrants and communities of color are so strong.”

The AP-NORC poll, which surveyed 2,596 adults from April 16-20, reflects a sampling error margin of plus or minus 2.6 percentage points.