- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:21 am
Criticism of New York City’s Plan to Close Rikers Island
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced the city’s latest strategy to close the Rikers Island Jail Complex by 2032 during a press conference on November 20, 2026, at City Hall in New York City. The plan proposes replacing Rikers with 4,100 borough-based jail cells. This number appears inadequate for a city with 8.5 million residents and nearly 500,000 reported crimes annually.
Mamdani’s strategy focuses on reducing the city’s jail population. He includes measures such as speeding up case processing, expanding alternative-to-incarceration programs, and improving bail access; these measures have been discussed in progressive circles for a decade. Yet, the plan lacks details on the current Rikers population and their potential release.
As of now, Rikers houses 6,640 inmates. Approximately 1,100 of them are sentenced or awaiting transfer, with little potential for early release. Thus, if the new jails were operational today, they would offer about 3,000 beds for the remaining 5,606 inmates awaiting trial. Of these, 1,433 face murder charges, and 2,625 are accused of violent felonies like attempted murder or robbery. This totals 4,058 inmates, nearly filling all new jail beds. With only 3,000 beds available, around 1,000 defendants with severe charges would be released.
This plan leaves no space for Rikers’ 1,282 non-violent felons and 269 misdemeanor inmates, all with prior offenses. The 2019 bail reform laws allow bail only if these inmates have committed another crime while on probation or have multiple felony convictions. Few judges set bail, resulting in more individuals being released.
The mayor’s plan to decrease jail numbers by 800 beds relies on accelerating court proceedings. However, NYC courts have a backlog of 13,253 criminal cases, a 41% increase since 2019, while other parts of New York state saw only an 862-case increase. Speedy-trial dismissals have surged 620% in NYC.
In contrast to other plans, Mamdani’s strategy claims to be “The First Comprehensive Plan to Close Rikers Island.” Critics argue it resembles prior efforts by Judge Jonathan Lippmann and Mayors Bill DeBlasio and Eric Adams. Concerns remain about releasing individuals with criminal histories. The city may need an additional 5,000-bed facility on Rikers Island as a contingency if local community jails fail to meet demand.
Jim Quinn, a retired prosecutor from the Queens District Attorney’s Office, critiques the plan. He emphasizes the importance of preparing for potential failures in the city’s approach to managing the incarcerated population.