- November 22, 2026
- Updated 9:59 am
Federal Judge in Colorado Orders Release of Man Detained by ICE
A federal judge in Colorado has ordered the immediate release of Edgardo Garcia Vargas, a man arrested by immigration agents just minutes after being freed from detention. The judge, S. Kato Crews, accused the government of an ongoing due process violation and warned officials they risk contempt proceedings if he is detained again without a hearing.
Judge Crews, a Biden appointee, highlighted that Garcia Vargas was released in accordance with a prior court order. However, he was swiftly arrested by ICE before leaving the detention facility. In a statement dated November 3, Crews criticized the administration’s actions, noting, “Once again, the cruelty appears to be the point.”
This incident occurs amidst increasing tensions between the Trump administration and the judiciary over aggressive immigration enforcement actions. Federal courts have been challenging the administration’s detention strategies, with some judges accusing immigration authorities of non-compliance with legal orders.
The Trump administration has been conducting large-scale deportation operations aimed at boosting arrests and removals. In Colorado, immigration arrests have surged as reflected in federal data obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. Arrests rose from 259 in March to 499 by July 2026, with 549 recorded in July 2025.
Despite the government’s argument that Garcia Vargas had been technically released and that the court’s habeas relief had been satisfied, Crews disagreed. He asserted that Garcia Vargas effectively remained in custody since his initial arrest. Crews emphasized that accepting the government’s stance would undermine habeas relief and encourage manipulation of legal processes.
No person would have felt free to leave under these circumstances,” Crews wrote.
Garcia Vargas argued that his initial arrest contravened his due process rights due to the absence of a warrant. A habeas corpus petition challenges the legality of someone’s detention. Since the government did not respond to this petition, the court acknowledged Garcia Vargas’ due process claim as uncontested.
Crews ruled that the re-detention of Garcia Vargas “mere minutes after his purported release was no release at all,” further constituting a violation of his due process rights. The judge mandated his immediate release and instructed the administration to submit a status report within three days to confirm his release.
Furthermore, the judge prohibited the authorities from re-arresting Garcia Vargas without a bond hearing to prove he poses a flight risk or a danger to the community. The government bears the burden of proof, and Garcia Vargas is entitled to legal representation.
Crews warned that another arrest without due process could lead to contempt proceedings, noting that the involved parties should prepare to justify their actions in court if such events transpire.
The case involves named individuals including Juan Baltazar, warden of the Aurora Contract Detention Facility, David Venturella, acting ICE director, and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin.
This ruling is part of an ongoing legal debate over ICE’s arrest methods in Colorado. Another federal judge, R. Brooke Jackson, has also stated the agency previously violated restrictions on warrantless arrests, following an incident involving an 18-year-old who sustained injuries. The government is appealing this injunction, with oral arguments expected soon.
Meanwhile, ICE has been increasing its detention capacity in Colorado. Reports have indicated the detainment facilities could double in size as enforcement heightens.