Is American Democracy Worth Preserving?

American democracy has faced criticism lately, with many questioning its effectiveness. While it has its challenges, authoritarian regimes often result in disastrous outcomes. Examples abound in countries like Russia, Belarus, and North Korea, where dictators have brought about widespread corruption and misery.

In the United States, the shift towards authoritarianism under Donald Trump is concerning. The rampant corruption within the executive branch highlights how power can lead to serious ethical breaches.

If authoritarian rule is not suitable, alternative forms of governance such as rule by the wealthy or hereditary aristocracy don’t appeal to Americans either. Current dissatisfaction with democracy might stem from the erosion of its fundamental pillars: the rule of law, educated voters, and a free press.

The rule of law is crucial to ensuring citizens receive the leaders they elect. Independent judiciary commitments have been compromised by political interference.

The Supreme Court’s decisions on gerrymandering and campaign finance further threaten electoral integrity, while the Department of Justice’s nonpartisan nature has diminished.

Democratic health also relies on educating citizens capable of discerning truth. Extremism diverts attention from essential educational values, leaving 43 million American adults functionally illiterate and prone to partisan thinking instead of reasoned judgment.

A robust, ethical, competitive press is vital for democracy. Unfortunately, media consolidation, supported by the Trump administration, stifles original reporting and promotes conglomerated biases. The press grows less reliable while social media becomes the dominant news source despite being unchecked and biased.

Strengthening the pillars of democracy requires immediate action to address declining confidence in political systems and institutions. If democracy is to thrive, these foundations must be bolstered promptly.

Thomas G. Moukawsher, a former Connecticut judge and American Bar Association leader, details these concerns with a call to action.