- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:31 am
Jewish Doctor Receives Exemption from Union Membership Over Religious Beliefs
- 19 Views
- admin
- November 12, 2026
- Health Public Health
A Jewish physician in Philadelphia successfully obtained an exemption from union membership and related fees due to his religious beliefs. Dr. Jacob Agronin, working at Temple University Hospital, challenged the mandate to support a union that he believed conflicted with his faith.
America First Legal (AFL) intervened on Agronin’s behalf, negotiating with the Committee of Interns and Residents (CIR), which is affiliated with the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 1957. AFL argued that the union’s stance, particularly its support of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel, posed an issue for Agronin due to his religious convictions.
CIR’s existing agreement with the hospital required employees to join the union or pay agency fees. Megan Redshaw, counsel for AFL, highlighted that Agronin’s objection was not to the union’s political speech rights. Rather, it was to mandatory financial support of union positions that conflicted with his personal beliefs.
Eventually, the union granted the accommodation, eliminating membership and fee obligations. Redshaw noted that Agronin had not paid dues nor signed any membership documents. She explained that his religious objections were based on Jewish teachings.
The union has expressed its role, claiming to represent over 40,000 resident physicians. It stated its mission to enhance residency training, patient care, and healthcare access. However, it faced criticism for devoting member dues to political causes that were not transparent to new members.
Recent CIR resolutions, such as ‘Housestaff for Human Rights’ and ‘Housestaff Against Apartheid,’ criticized Israeli policies and endorsed the BDS movement. Following a violent incident in Israel and Palestine in October 2023, CIR issued a statement mourning the casualties and calling for the restoration of essential services in Gaza while advocating for a ceasefire.
In May 2026, Agronin addressed a House Committee expressing concerns over some elements of CIR’s statement. He criticized the statement for equating the responsibility for casualties on both sides and for omitting condemnation of Hamas.
Redshaw emphasized that similar religious objections could lead to exemptions from union fees entirely, noting that the union could steer reimbursed fees towards charitable causes aligned with its views. However, in certain states, such requests could lead to an entire exemption from union participation.
The union and Temple University Hospital have not provided comments on this exemption.