- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:26 am
NYPD Unit Disbandment Sparks Safety Concerns
Retired police officer voices concerns over NYC safety
A retired police sergeant with extensive experience cautioned against bringing family members to New York City due to the disbandment of a specialized NYPD unit. Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith, who has a long career in law enforcement, shared her concerns exclusively with Fox News Digital.
NYPD’s Strategic Response Group disbandment
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced the dismantling of the Strategic Response Group (SRG), a unit of about 500 officers focused on counterterrorism and managing large security events. This forms part of a wider plan to shift how protests are handled by the NYPD.
The mayor stated that separating counterterrorism from protest policing meets his campaign promises. Critics argue this move could disrupt effective emergency response.
“I wouldn’t take my family there right now,” Smith warned.
Smith highlights potential risks
Smith, with 29 years of experience in law enforcement, emphasized the significance of the SRG, given its officers’ unique training and collaboration in situations like active shooter incidents.
With events like the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade approaching, she warned that existing relationships and intelligence channels could suffer if operational roles are reshuffled.
“I’m concerned that intelligence could be ignored or lost during large-scale events,” she said.
Future changes and impacts
The department plans to transition responsibilities to a new First Amendment Support Team by 2027. Meanwhile, personnel from the SRG will integrate into the Counterterrorism Bureau.
Assistant Commissioner Brad Weeks confirmed parade security will remain unaffected in the short term.
Mayor responds to security concerns
Mayor Mamdani defended his decision, stating that protest responses should not equate to terrorism response. The planned changes restrict police tactics, such as removing the use of long guns and tear gas during demonstrations.
A transition to a civilian-led de-escalation division is planned by 2028, focusing on dialogue and engagement with protest organizers.
The safety of New Yorkers remains a priority, with police presence assured in cases of violence.
Community reactions and petitions
Community members and organizations expressed mixed reactions. Some praised the move as a step toward handling protests differently. Other organizations, like the National Police Association, have initiated petitions to reinstate the SRG.
The petition gathered nearly 2,000 signatures shortly after launch as community members expressed concerns about public safety.
Commissioner Jessica Tisch reiterated the NYPD’s commitment to maintaining necessary security measures and resource allocation to protect the city effectively.