- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:31 am
Supreme Court Signals Support for Catholic Preschools in Colorado Discrimination Case
- 33 Views
- admin
- November 3, 2026
- Court News
The Supreme Court’s conservative justices have expressed support for Catholic preschools opposing Colorado’s nondiscrimination pledge that includes students with transgender or gay parents. This case questions whether a state can impose conditions on public funding which conflict with certain religious beliefs.
Colorado’s Universal Preschool Program, started in 2023, offers 15 hours of tuition-free preschool weekly to every 4-year-old. Participation is open to all public, private, and religious schools that agree to a nondiscrimination clause affecting sexual orientation and gender identity.
Justice Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett challenged Colorado’s conditions, while Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson highlighted the request for a religious exemption that no secular school possesses. Chief Justice John Roberts holds a potential deciding vote, probing both arguments.
“I’m not quite sure how you limit the applicability of your principle,” Roberts stated while questioning the lawyer for the parishes, Nicholas Reaves, about potential broader implications on driver licenses and other benefits.
The core conflict touches on two different precedents, Sherbert v. Verner (1963) and Employment Division v. Smith (1990). Sherbert protects religious practices from government denial without strict scrutiny. Smith supports laws uniformly applicable, regardless of religious impact. The court declined to reconsider Smith.
Justice Gorsuch accused Colorado of bypassing recent pro-religious school rulings: “The Constitution tends to deal in substances, not in shadows and procedures.” Justice Kavanaugh remarked that secular preferences existed, questioning the exclusion of Catholic schools.
Sotomayor pressed Reaves to clarify if schools would deny enrollment based on parents’ sexual orientation, receiving an affirmative response with limits.
A question arose about racial exclusion, which Reaves denied, maintaining the schools wouldn’t automatically reject children of gay couples.
Justice Kagan and Jackson raised issues about logically distinguishing between objections based on sexuality and race. Colorado’s aim, Norton explained, was equal opportunity across all preschools.
The Trump administration had sided with the parishes earlier, urging revisiting precedents to solidify religious liberties within public programs.
Archdiocese-affiliated groups sued following Colorado’s denial of exemption requests, aiming to admit families following Catholic sex and gender beliefs. Colorado argued such policies might discriminate based on sexual orientation or gender status.
Plaintiffs cited First Amendment rights and argued discriminatory practice due to exceptions offered to other providers. Lower courts have so far dismissed these claims.
Colorado has previously lost Supreme Court battles over similar LGBT issues, including conversion therapy bans and service refusals by a web designer and a baker related to religious beliefs.
The Sheley family, litigants in this case seeking preschool funding for a Catholic school’s admission policy, have faced financial shortfalls due to denied exemption. A decision is anticipated by the end of June.