- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:16 am
The Challenges of Elder Care and the Growing Responsibilities on Families
- 17 Views
- admin
- November 20, 2026
- Health Public Health
A Saturday Night Live sketch introducing a fictional service called “Sister” has gained significant attention. It humorously questioned why families pay for elder care when daughters often provide it for free. This sketch resonated with many as it highlights the familiar and challenging reality faced by numerous American families.
In 2025, a report from AARP and the National Alliance for Caregiving revealed that 63 million Americans were providing ongoing care to family members or friends, marking a nearly 50% increase over the past decade. Notably, 61% of these caregivers are women. Research indicates that those stepping into caregiving roles often start with better health and finances. However, over time, they experience declines in both areas compared to non-caregivers.
Medicare’s Limited Coverage
Medicare, the federal health insurance program for most adults 65 and older, does not typically cover long-term care or assistance with daily activities. It focuses on hospital stays, doctor visits, and certain home health services. Those needing help with tasks like bathing or meal preparation usually cannot depend on Medicare for that support. This limitation can lead to significant financial strain.
For example, in 2025, the median cost of a home health aide was $6,688 per month, while assisted living averaged $6,141 monthly. A Harvard study found that 76% of households age 75 and older could not afford daily assistance from home health aides while managing housing and basic expenses.
Medicaid: Access and Limitations
Medicaid, another public health insurance program, often provides coverage for personal assistance at home. It funded nearly two-thirds of U.S. home care spending in 2023. However, Medicaid requires meeting financial criteria, which can differ by state, and many must deplete savings before qualifying. Even then, states control services, often resulting in waitlists for needed care.
The Caregiver Workforce Shortage
Even with coverage, finding reliable care is challenging. Direct care workers, including home health aides, face recruitment and retention issues. The median hourly wage was $17.99 in 2025, slightly more than fast-food workers, making these positions hard to fill. This problem may worsen due to immigration policy impacts, as one-third of these workers are foreign-born.
Family Caregivers and Financial Impact
When professional care is insufficient or unaffordable, family members, particularly daughters, often step in. This unpaid role can mean reduced work hours or job loss, affecting immediate income and future retirement savings. The Family and Medical Leave Act provides 12 weeks of unpaid leave for eligible caregivers, but chronic conditions can extend beyond this period, increasing financial strain, especially on women.
State and Government Initiatives
Some states have launched initiatives to bridge these gaps. Programs in California and New Jersey offer paid family leave. New York’s Medicaid compensates family caregivers, while Washington state contributes to long-term care coverage. Additionally, Kamala Harris advocated for expanding Medicare for more in-home services, though the proposal was not implemented after the 2024 election loss.
The SNL sketch humorously touched on family dynamics but underscores the serious issue of caregiving assignments. Government policies significantly influence why family members bear much of this responsibility. When public programs fail to cover essential care, the burden and associated costs often shift, typically to daughters.
By Jane Tavares, Senior Research Fellow and Lecturer of Gerontology, UMass Boston and Marc Cohen, Professor of Gerontology, UMass Boston.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.