- November 22, 2026
- Updated 8:36 am
The Need for a Revised Immigration Approach Amid Chronic Crises
- 33 Views
- admin
- November 4, 2026
- World News
On August 20, the United States deported over 160 people to Haiti on its first removal flight since ending temporary protected status (TPS) for around 350,000 Haitians. The flight landed in Cap-Haïtien instead of the capital Port-au-Prince due to ongoing insecurity making the airport unsafe for U.S. commercial flights. TPS allows eligible foreign nationals in the U.S. to stay and work legally when conditions in their home country prevent safe return. Haiti’s 2010 earthquake, which killed more than 220,000 people and displaced 1.5 million, justified the TPS designation. For 15 years, various administrations renewed Haiti’s temporary protection. However, this June, a Supreme Court decision ended this protection for Haitians.
Advocates and critics of TPS focus on the 15-year period as evidence of their positions. Both ignore a deeper issue: What action is needed when a disaster becomes chronic?
My parents emigrated from Haiti to the U.S. in the 1980s. Though their story isn’t about TPS, it shows that migration often begins long before disasters strike. My work, developing networks to connect people and economies, has reinforced this lesson. A well-designed network survives losing a link but needs complete recovery to avoid vulnerability. Without investment, it might not regain full capacity.
Between 2008 and 2023, according to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Center, about 44 natural disasters caused approximately 2.9 million internal displacements in Haiti, a country of around 10 million. Each disaster struck before recovery from the prior one was possible. Meanwhile, Haitian governments faced political instability and chronic underinvestment in infrastructure, leaving barely 1 in 10 rural residents with electricity. By the mid-2010s, approximately 80% of urban households relied on charcoal, driving wood demand and migration to cities lacking jobs and housing. This pattern is worldwide as climate and disasters hit already strained systems.
Rather than temporary renewals or terminations following country assessments, Congress should create a formal response for when emergencies become prolonged national crises. I propose a two-step national stability review by the Departments of Homeland Security and State, triggered when a country maintains TPS for 10 consecutive years. This review would publish findings not on whether initial crisis conditions persist, but if persistence indicates a chronic crisis.
A situation is chronic when severe, durable conditions, worsened by environmental shocks, make safe return within a set period unfeasible, and do not support returning populations. Not every prolonged crisis would alter designation.
If conditions are chronic, a second-stage assessment examines TPS holders of 10 years for eligibility to apply for permanent residence, following screenings. The assessment would ensure that relief fits the problem’s nature while being selective. Congress has previously offered permanent relief to specific groups and considered broader measures like the American Dream and Promise Act. Yet, these often focus on nationality and amnesty timelines, promising permanent status. A national stability review would determine if TPS suits the crisis’s nature and persistence.
The U.S. cannot promise permanent residency to billions facing environmental vulnerability or governance issues. A national stability review wouldn’t admit migrants or automatically change statuses but would avoid decade-long protection renewals that suddenly declare a country healed or neglected. Temporary protection for 15 years highlights that a crisis might not be temporary. Earthquakes or hurricanes end, but systemic failures in countries where planes cannot safely land indicate a different problem level. Congress should differentiate between acute emergencies and structural weaknesses, providing a nuanced humanitarian path for chronic conditions.
Alex-Handrah Aimé is Vice President of Network Investments at Meta, focusing on infrastructure connecting data centers. Born in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, she is a PD Soros Fellow and Public Voices Fellow with the OpEd Project.