Evaluating Xi Jinping’s Meetings: Trump vs. Putin

Contrasting Visits: Trump’s and Putin’s Time in China

In a span of less than a week, President Xi Jinping of China hosted visits from U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. While the ceremonies bore similarities, there were distinct differences marking each meeting.

Airport Reception: A Diplomatic Signal

Airport ceremonies are a key indicator in China’s diplomatic protocol. Putin was welcomed by Foreign Minister Wang Yi, adhering to standard protocol. In contrast, Trump was greeted by Vice President Han Zheng, who holds a higher national rank.

Agendas and Discussions

The visits had contrasting outcomes. After Trump’s departure, there were no major breakthroughs, although future trade deals were hinted at. A joint statement was absent. In Putin’s case, a joint statement with Xi addressed topics like nuclear security and wildlife conservation. Twenty documents were signed, although no significant new agreements emerged.

Delegation Composition

The U.S. delegation included fewer top-level officials but highlighted business leaders from various sectors. In contrast, Russia’s delegation had numerous high-ranking officials focusing on energy and banking, reflecting different priorities.

Cultural Engagements

Putin attended a photo exhibition displaying the legacy of Russia-China relations, while Trump’s itinerary included the Temple of Heaven, showcasing China’s rich history. These events underscored the unique aspects of each visit.

Banquets and Culinary Delights

The banquet for Putin included traditional dishes like Peking duck, which was also served to Trump. However, Trump’s banquet was publicly broadcast, unlike Putin’s more private dining experience. Both events featured music from the People’s Liberation Army orchestra.

Private Meetings and Departure

Putin’s schedule included a late-night tea session. Conversely, Trump was granted a rare visit to Zhongnanhai gardens. Notably, Putin’s departure was attended by Vice Premier Zhang Guoqing, while Trump was seen off by Foreign Minister Wang Yi, both carrying significant political weight.

Long-term Relationships: Presidents and Xi

Xi and Putin have maintained a close relationship with frequent visits and meetings since 2013. In contrast, Trump’s two visits to China indicate a less frequent interaction than Xi’s engagements with former U.S. Presidents.